Insights

No proof of the condo guide, no binding deal: what DiCenzo v. Sadeghyar means for buyers and builders

한국어로 읽기

Ontario’s Condominium Act, 1998 requires a builder to give every buyer of a new residential condominium unit two documents: a disclosure statement and the province’s condominium guide. A March 2026 Superior Court decision shows how much depends on the second one, and on whether the builder can prove it was delivered.

The rule

Since January 1, 2021, section 72(1) of the Act has required builders to deliver the condominium guide with the disclosure statement. Section 72(2) sets out the consequence: the purchase agreement is not binding on the buyer until both have been delivered. Section 73 gives the buyer 10 days to rescind, and that window opens only once the buyer has the guide, the disclosure statement and a copy of the agreement signed by both sides.

The dispute

In DiCenzo (Linden Park) Holdings Inc. v. Sadeghyar, 2026 ONSC 1566, the buyer signed an electronic agreement in March 2022 for a new unit in Hamilton priced at just over $1 million, and paid $121,098 in deposits. When closing arrived in February 2024, he could not obtain financing and the sale did not close. The builder resold the unit for about $300,000 less, then applied to keep the deposit and recover the rest of its losses. The buyer applied in turn for a declaration that the agreement had never bound him, because he had never received the guide.

Why the signed acknowledgment was not enough

The builder relied on a schedule to the agreement in which the buyer confirmed by e-signature that he had received the guide. The court gave it little weight. The same acknowledgment confirmed receipt of a fully signed agreement and the disclosure statement, and the evidence showed the buyer could not have had either on the day he signed it. The builder could show when it emailed other key documents, but it had no record of ever sending the guide. The court found that the guide was never delivered.

The result

Because the guide was never delivered, the agreement never became binding on the buyer and the 10-day rescission period never began. The court ordered the builder to return the $121,098 deposit with interest, and the buyer recovered $31,000 in costs.

The court rejected the builder’s other arguments. The buyer’s experience as a licensed real estate agent did not relieve the builder of its duty. Paying deposits and signing amendments did not mean he had affirmed the agreement or was estopped from relying on the Act, because under the Act the point of no return is accepting a deed to the unit.

What buyers should take from it

  • Check what you received, and whenThe cooling-off period depends on the dates you actually received each of the three documents, not on what an acknowledgment form says.
  • Do not act on your ownRescission requires written notice under the Act. Refusing to close without proper advice can put you in breach.
  • Financing trouble is not a defenceIn Chen v. Brookfield Residential (Ontario) Limited, 2022 ONCA 887, a buyer facing a low appraisal tried to rescind by alleging a material change. The Court of Appeal held the notice was invalid and the buyer was in breach. A buyer who abandons a binding agreement can lose the deposit and be liable for the builder’s resale losses.
  • Confirm the property is a condominiumThese rules apply only to condominium units. Some townhouses that look like ordinary homes are registered as condominiums; the agreement and the proposed condominium plan will tell you.

What builders should take from it

  • Keep proof of delivery for the guideRecord delivery of the guide as carefully as the disclosure statement. In an electronic sale, keep a record of the file actually sent and when.
  • Make acknowledgments accurateAn acknowledgment that confirms documents the buyer could not yet have had invites a court to discount the whole document.

The limits of the decision

The outcome turned on the evidence. A buyer who did receive the guide, and let the 10-day period pass, is in a very different position, although other grounds such as a material change to the disclosure statement may still need review. This is also a recent first-instance decision, so check whether it has been appealed before relying on it.

If you are approaching a condominium closing, or you are a builder reviewing your sales documents, book a consultation or email info@lumenllp.ca.

This article is general information about Ontario law as of its publication date. It is not legal advice. For advice about your situation, book a consultation.

Discuss your matter

Tell us what happened. We will tell you where you stand.

Consultations by appointment at our Toronto and Markham offices, or by video.