Shareholder Disputes
When co-owners of a private company fall out, the business, its value and your investment are all at risk. We act for shareholders and companies to resolve the dispute through negotiation, a buy-out or the courts.
Shareholder disputes in private companies usually begin with a breakdown in trust: one owner is shut out of decisions, money is moved without explanation, or the owners disagree about the direction or sale of the business. Because the owners are often also directors, employees or family members, the dispute affects every part of the company.
Common disputes
- Exclusion and deadlockA shareholder is removed as a director or employee, denied information, or the owners cannot make decisions.
- Diverted money and opportunitiesExcessive salaries, undisclosed payments, or business taken to a competing company.
- Buy-outs and valuationDisagreement over whether an owner can be bought out, and at what price.
- Shareholder agreement disputesEnforcing or interpreting buy-sell, shotgun, non-compete and dispute resolution clauses.
- DilutionShares issued to reduce a minority shareholder’s stake or control.
Remedies available
Depending on the facts, a shareholder can bring an oppression claim, seek leave to bring a derivative action on the company’s behalf, ask the court to order a buy-out at fair value, enforce the shareholder agreement, or in serious cases ask the court to wind up the company. Interim relief, such as an order preserving assets or restoring access to records, may be available while the case proceeds.
Many shareholder disputes end in a negotiated buy-out. Building a strong legal position early is what gives you leverage in that negotiation.
Frequently asked questions
Can the majority force me out of the company?
The majority can often remove you as a director or employee, but that does not end your rights as a shareholder. If you were excluded in a way that defeats your reasonable expectations, you may have an oppression claim, which can include an order that your shares be bought at fair value.
How are my shares valued in a dispute?
Courts generally use fair market value as of a date chosen to be fair to the parties, usually with the help of business valuators. Whether a discount applies for a minority interest depends on the circumstances and any shareholder agreement.
Do I need a shareholder agreement to bring a claim?
No. The oppression remedy and other statutory rights exist whether or not there is a shareholder agreement, although an agreement may affect what your reasonable expectations were and how the dispute must be resolved.
This page is part of our Commercial & Civil Litigation practice. For advice about your situation, book a consultation.